Rountdable #4 - Part 2 : Middle Infield

HARPER

You bring up the Boone Boys but that's just the undercard for the main event Triple Threat match; Belliard, Lopez, and Guzman. Three enter - 2 leave. My money is on Belliard and Guzman (who God as my witness won't reach .700 for his OPS this year.)

BASIL

I'm not so sure it's a three-man cage match, at least for now. Guzman seems safe: he's got the contract thing, the contract year thing, the (finally) healthy thing, and the (fluky) batting average thing. That's a lot of things!

Ultimately, I think Lopez has a little bit of an inside track on the starting job at second. Belliard has signed as a utility guy, agreed to an extension at least in part as a utility guy, and is paid like a utility guy. And, when it comes down to it, Manny's a very smart guy and he knows Cristian Guzman cannot be anyone's best option to lead off. Lopez might be.

CHRIS

If he's that smart, then he'll realize that Guzman isn't an answer at short either. If I had to bet, I'd say that Belliard and Lopez will have the most PA of the trio by the end of the season. Those two certainly give the team the best chance to win.

BASIL

Maybe so. But Manny's also street smart -- or so it seems -- and the line on the street is that Guzman finally has a chance to reclaim value on the deal. (Disregard for a moment that the deal was a loser for all time by August of 2005, if not earlier.) So, until Guzman disabuses the notion, I'm thinking he's given some pretty wide latitude (or longitude?).

One other factor -- maybe not the most important but it's out there -- is that Guzman is tied in at one position. Flop and Belliard, at least theoretically, can contribute at both short and second. That makes them more natural bench options.

However, your outlook on such things seems correct to me when you apportion plate appearances as you do. A lineup isn't carved on tablets, a season is long, and there's plenty of time to administer SS/2B PT in a reasonable manner, given the constraints of the roster.

HARPER

Yes, but everyone, the manager, the players, the fans, want a general sense of stability. Musical positions maybe the reality but certainly not the ideal. The starting nine on Opening Day will be taken as the hopeful starting nine for the Nats for 2008. And the 2008 Nats are still looking at promoting these guys for deadline deals. That leans toward a Guzman / Belliard starting duo. If they do well...Lopez may never see those ABs.

I guess is makes sense not to start Belliard if you think Lopez is the future, but do you? I don't.

CHRIS

I like Lopez' future a hell of a lot more than I like Belliard's, given the latter's age and cup size. (Up top, not down low)

Stability is great, but that shouldn't be the goal in and off itself. Look at the Harper's favorite team, the Yankees. Til Matsui, it was a roving hoard of left-fielders, and they managed ok. They seem to have had more success with instability, even!

The overall point behind what you're saying is right. The team doesn't have any upper-level infielders ready to go. There is no MI of the future. So maybe that's why it's important to see what Lopez can give you, since he's the youngest of the trio, and might need to fill the gap til someone like Ian Desmond can show up and disappoint in three years.

BASIL

I guess with Lopez it ultimately comes down to whether anyone can believe in him going forward anymore. If so, then I suppose he's worth the most playing time among the middle infielders (and certainly in a Lopez vs. Belliard head-on comparison). If not, well . . . he might as well have been non-tendered or dumped for a few pennies on the dollar. It's nice to win an arbitration hearing, but $4.9M is $4.9M, and there exists the (presumed) possibility that he could prove a distraction.

Not that Stan believes in team chemistry . . .

CHRIS

(Or spending money)

Yeah, it's a cheapshot. Deal!

BASIL

Or, in the case of almost any free agent out there, no deal.

(Whoops, forgot about OD Perez!)

HARPER

You must know that I wouldn't personally choose to start Guzman over
Lopez. I did compare him to the festering corpse of Honus Wagner and
all. Just trying to predict what is going to happen and this crystal
ball is seeing Belliard. Perhaps because Belliard is more
ball-shaped.